I think it’s a safe assumption that thrift stores want the obvious stuff, like vintage clothes that still have some life left or maybe an old end table or two. But after digging into a few donation center programs (and realizing how much junk I’d been tossing), I learned that there are places that welcome a surprising range of things. When given to the right place, these unexpected donations could end up being exactly what someone else needed.
1Old Eyeglasses and Hearing Aids
Thrift stores often partner with recycling programs that refurbish glasses for people in need. Before donating, wipe the lenses, make sure the frames aren’t broken, and tuck them into a small case or zip bag. The Lions Clubs International Eyeglass Recycling Program accepts eyeglasses and hearing aids through local drop boxes and Walmart Vision Centers, where they’re sorted and sent to global vision clinics.
2Hardware and Small Tools
A box of loose screws or an old wrench might look like junk, but hardware stores and home builders love thrifting this stuff. The trick is to sort and label everything, like only nails in one bag, knobs in another. Check for local tool libraries (mine is the literally called The Tool Library, and they have a wishlist of what they need). Some orgs might even be seeking donations of non-working tools and random hardware, since they can be resold for repair or repurposed by tinkerers.
3Pet Supplies
Many thrift stores coordinate directly with animal shelters to keep pet goods out of landfills. Clean bowls, washed blankets, and intact leashes can go a long way for rescue programs. If thrift stores aren’t accepting these items, seek out a local humane society or shelter. The Humane Society of New York recommends checking items for cleanliness and safety before donating—no frayed edges or lingering odors.
4Mismatched Cookware
Most donation centers will take your lone pot lid or stray saucepan, as long as it’s clean and in good condition. I usually group pieces with a rubber band and note whether it’s a “lid only” or “pan only” so staff don’t assume it’s broken. Most Goodwill locations list cookware, including lids, as an acceptable item in their housewares section.
5Fabric Scraps
Old pillowcases, curtains, and even fabric remnants can often be repurposed by crafters and quilters. Wash and fold everything neatly, then label it as “scrap fabric” or “craft textiles” so store staff can shelve it appropriately. Even imperfect pieces, when organized well, can be recycled or resold to makers.
6Office Supplies
Most thrift stores (and even the Human Society for pets!) accept unused or lightly used office supplies. Teachers and artists often buy them for creative reuse. They’re also a great way to help stock community programs that rely on low-cost supplies to run workshops and classes.
7Off-Season Holiday Decor
Thrift stores don’t mind getting Christmas ornaments in July or Halloween decorations in February—in fact, they prefer it. Donating out of season gives stores time to sort and store items before demand spikes. Just make sure everything is clean, unbroken, and neatly boxed so glitter and tinsel don’t scatter through other donations.
