Lauren Thomann is an antique dealer, freelance writer, and editor with nearly two decades of experience. She specializes in antiques, antique jewelry, old houses, vintage design, and lifestyle content.

Meet the Heirloom Pie Safe That Became the Heart of This Southern Cottage

Sara McDaniel blends old and new in her Minden cottage, where every room tells a story—and one pie safe says it all.

I had the pleasure of speaking with Sara McDaniel of Simply Southern Cottage for a recent article on Better Homes & Gardens about hosting mom. I just loved what she had to say and became intrigued by what else she’s doing (restoring old homes with care).

So, of course, I wanted to know if she had any heirlooms she wanted to share, and get some insight into how she approaches rehabilitating old houses. Here’s how she proves that even if an heirloom is nearly destroyed, all hope is not lost.

Sara McDaniel from Simply Southern Cottage

Meet the Collector

Sara McDaniel is an old home restorer and the founder of Simply Southern Cottage.

Heirloom Stories Q&A

Do you have a favorite heirloom? What’s its story?

My favorite heirloom item in my home is my great-grandmother’s pie safe. Growing up, my granny had this in her outdoor kitchen (the one she used for canning and frying fish), and I distinctly remember playing with it; putting away dishes, exploring the cupboards, and setting out pretend tea parties.

When my papaw and granny passed away in 2004 and 2006, respectively, we had to clean out their home, and by this time, the pie safe was in shambles and had been reduced to a pile of wood. I saved it because I knew I wanted to restore it one day.  

That day came when I renovated my cottage in Minden, Louisiana. I had the perfect nook for it and a skilled carpenter to put it back together. And today, it proudly sits in my home, even housing some of my granny’s dishes. 

Antique pie safe
Credit: Simply Southern Cottage

Your restoration projects blend Southern charm with historic preservation. How do you decide which original elements to keep and which ones to modernize?

In all my renovations, I strive to preserve as many of the original details as possible. In my personal cottage, I kept all the original light fixtures, doors, and door hardware, as well as a fold-out ironing board and shiplap, and repurposed the original kitchen cabinets for use in other areas of the home.  

I always modernize things to make the home more energy efficient, such as the plumbing, HVAC, and electrical systems.  I strongly believe it is OK to update those features while preserving much of the architectural integrity. Even when I add newer features, I try to choose period-appropriate pieces (like the tile) that will blend seamlessly into the home and not “stand out” as a new feature. 

Vintage style bedroom with shoplap
Credit: Simply Southern Cottage

What makes your designs feel soulful and lived-in?

This is a great question! I blend a LOT of thrifted decor pieces in with new, retail selections to truly create that heritage, cozy feel. Someone once told me that when they look at my home, they just want to grab a cup of hot cocoa and a blanket and sit for a spell.  

I also incorporate as many of the original details of a home as I can to truly tie together the history of the home with its modern residents.

Whether it’s my home or a space I’m designing, my greatest desire is for the home to feel cozy and warm while also bringing joy to your heart. My designs initially started more neutral but have evolved over the years into more pattern play and color. It truly depends on whether I’m designing a space that will be lived in, such as a home, or a space that will be experienced, like one of my short-term rentals. But either way, the space is cozy, warm, and full of joy. 

shop the look

The products featured here may contain affiliate links.

Was this article helpful?
Yes0No1
Worth $495? — Antique Painted Blanket Chest

Antique Paint Decorated blanket chest Grain Bin Dating to the 19th century, this antique painted blanket chest has the kind of worn folk-art surface collectors love, with painted decoration and old wood construction.

The finish shows age and wear—but at $495, does its primitive charm justify the price?

This poll contains an affiliate link.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. By clicking “Accept“, you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy. Accept Read More